DS: this situation seems kind of weird…?
Posted on January 29th, 2011 by admin
My sister keeps her dogs outside, in a kennel, pretty much all the time. I personally think it’s cruel, especially since the only attention they get daily is being fed. When they are allowed out of the kennel, they are harassed by my nieces. Once when I was over visiting, my nieces started a game of chasing the little jack russell around the yard and hitting him with plastic toy golf clubs. I once watched my brother in law smack their red bone coon hound in the head because my niece got caught up in her chain- not exactly sure how this is her fault. They rarely clean out the kennel, so it becomes very gross. It’s also pretty cold outside, and the dogs still stay out, getting their water changed twice a day to keep it thawed instead of the normal once a day.
Well, someone called the humane society on my sister, saying that the dogs didn’t have proper shelter. After they came, my sister specifically told them they weren’t allowed on the property, but they could look at the dog’s living arrangements through the alley that is right behind their yard, right next to where the kennel is for the dogs. After the people from the humane society actually came onto the property and my sister told them to get off, they said that the shelter that was provided was good, they just had to buy a heated water bowl, which my sister said was bogus.
Later, the police came, wanting to arrest my sister, not exactly sure why. They only left after my brother in law threatened to sue the humane society for coming in the yard, and after they agreed to get the dogs licensed which only cost a total of $20.
I definitely don’t agree with my sister and the way she treats the animals, and I’m happy they were chastised for it. However, does the humane society even have a viable reason to want my sister arrested? And were they in the fault for entering the property when they were specifically told not to? And most importantly, was it really necessary to go through all that trouble so my sister and her husband would pay $20 to license the dogs?
Sorry for the length…
No, I wasn’t there. From what she told me, she didn’t really threaten them, but she wasn’t exactly a friendly person to them either. Who knows though, I don’t particularly trust my sister and her story telling.
I would understand if there were reports of the animals being abused, but the only report they mentioned was poor housing, and the people from the Humane Society even said that the shelter was adequate. So, after saying that the dogs were fine where they were and didn’t have to be seized, they wanted to arrest my sister…
Without knowing where you are it would be impossible to answer. And of course, we only have one side of the story. Personal experience has taught me that people always "forget" details that may color them in a poor light. No offence, but there isn’t a doubt in my mind that there are some details, even minor, that she has left out.
These are just some suggestions.
"And were they in the fault for entering the property when they were specifically told not to?"
No. Whether they were legally on her property or not, it does not negate whatever illegal act she is alleged to have committed.
"does the humane society even have a viable reason to want my sister arrested? "
It all depends on what transpired. Aside from threats, which you have already mentioned, it may be possible that they did have lawful authority to be on the property and her interference/refusal to allow them to do a proper investigation that they are legally allowed to do may be an illegal act in itself, like obstruction of an investigation. Again, just an idea, depends on your laws.
Or she could have just really pissed thexaggerated they exagerated a story to cause trouble for her.
Either way, there is no way of knowing without knowing what she was supposed to be arrested for.
Lack of housing is considered abuse.